Repair or Replace? A Decision Guide for Household Appliances

Repair or Replace? A Decision Guide for Household Appliances

The 50% rule, device age, energy maths and board repair for the right decision.

When a household appliance breaks the first question is always the same: repair or replace? It is emotionally easy to say "let's buy a new one", but this decision should often be made with numbers. The practical framework below helps you make a choice that protects both your wallet and the environment.

The 50% rule

If the repair cost exceeds 50% of the price of an equivalent new device, buying a new one is usually more sensible. If the repair is under 30%, repairing is generally more economical. In the 30-50% zone, the age of the device is decisive.

Device age and expected life

  • Washing machine: Average life 10-12 years. A bearing or pump fault under 8 years is worth repairing.
  • Dishwasher: 10-12 years. Heater, pump and board repairs are economical.
  • Fridge: 12-15 years. A compressor failure after 10 years may be a reason to replace.
  • Boiler: 12-15 years. Heat exchanger or board replacement is worth it up to 8 years; beyond 12 years a new condensing unit saves energy.
  • AC: 10-12 years. Gas refills and servicing are economical; in a compressor failure consider a new unit.

Energy efficiency maths

An old A+ fridge uses about 400 kWh a year, a new A-class about 150 kWh. At 3 TRY/kWh the yearly difference can be 750 TRY. For a 10-year-old fridge, buying a new one instead of an expensive compressor repair makes more sense when energy savings are considered.

A middle path for electronic board faults

A board fault alone does not end a device's life. Although a new board is expensive, repairing it in the workshop cuts cost by 60-70% and comes with a six-month warranty. In a board fault, ask for a repair quote before buying a new device.

Questions before deciding

  1. How old is the device?
  2. What percentage of the new price is the repair cost?
  3. Are you having a second fault in the same year?
  4. Are parts in stock and how long will repair take?
  5. How much energy will the new device save?

Honesty from a service company

A good service says so openly when repair is not sensible. We charge only the call-out fee for diagnosis from customers who do not go ahead with repair; for older devices we give a written repair-versus-replace cost comparison first.

For a quick first idea about your device, use our online diagnosis wizard, then book for a free repair-or-replace assessment.

Environmental impact

Manufacturing a washing machine causes roughly 300-400 kg of CO₂ equivalent emissions. Using the device for five more years significantly lowers both your budget and your carbon footprint compared with buying new.

WhatsApp +90 224 555 88 00 servis@hizirservis.com.tr